Обсуждение:Пенен, Жан-Поль

This page has been vandalized and, strangely enough, blocked. --86.205.118.135 20:08, 13 июня 2008 (UTC)cargese

This page is blocked because of systematic attempts from unregistered users to remove from the article all negative opinions about JP Penin. General policy of Wikipedia demands for neutral point of view which is present in the current version of the article: both positive and negative appraisals of Mr. Penin's book are cited. Андрей Романенко 14:35, 14 июня 2008 (UTC)

Well, a bio is a bio, not a discussion about a book. If so, should be also mentionned all the reviews of Penin's recordings... And also, why, in Penin's bio, was deleted the reference to his Fullbright scholarship award (1978)? Very easy to check.

--86.205.118.135 07:07, 15 июня 2008 (UTC)cargese

The book is reviewed in the article in the widest way as the most contradictory of Mr. Penin's work. But you are welcome to propose here some other citations dealing with Mr. Penin recordings or concerts or something. These citations will be transfered to the article if they would be based on independent, reliable and verifiable sources. You may also propose a reference to any independent source confirming Mr. Penin's Fullbright scholarship. Андрей Романенко 09:38, 15 июня 2008 (UTC)

www.fulbright-france.org/pdf/cfa-newsletter-02.pdf - Page 4 : les Artistes Fulbrighte--86.205.118.135 15:03, 15 июня 2008 (UTC)cargese--86.205.118.135 15:07, 15 июня 2008 (UTC)cargese

Added, thank you. Андрей Романенко 15:36, 15 июня 2008 (UTC)